The Best Milkshake Makers
You might be wondering whether you really need another appliance taking up counter space. After all, can’t a regular blender do the job? Technically, yes, but here’s what we learned during our testing process.
Traditional blenders struggle with the thick consistency that defines a great milkshake. They’re designed to liquify ingredients, which works against you when you want that spoon-standing thickness. We found ourselves constantly stopping and scraping down the sides, adding extra liquid to keep the blades moving, and ultimately ending up with something closer to flavored milk than a proper shake.
Dedicated milkshake makers, on the other hand, are engineered specifically for this task. They use specialized mixing mechanisms that incorporate air while blending, creating that signature fluffy texture you get at ice cream shops. The motors are calibrated to handle frozen ingredients without overheating or burning out. Most importantly, they achieve consistent results without requiring you to babysit the machine.
Ready to buy? Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster Electric Drink Mixer is our #1 pick — see it on Amazon
Everything We Recommend
✅ We recommend these products based on an intensive research process that’s designed to cut through the noise and find the top products in this space. Guided by experts, we spend hours looking into the factors that matter to bring you these selections.
⭐ 2.5 million+ people assisted in the last 30 days ⭐
🏆
Versatile drink mixer creates milkshakes, lattes, fruit drinks, and cocktails, expanding your homemade beverage options easily.
Includes an extra large 28 oz stainless steel cup, ideal for mixing single or double servings with mix-ins.
Tilt-back head design allows easy ingredient access, cup removal, and dishwasher-safe spindle for simple cleanup.
Two-speed control lets you start gently and increase power to achieve smooth or thick textures precisely.
Compact countertop mixer also handles batters, eggs, and dressings, adding everyday convenience and kitchen style.
💎
Retro style blender recreates classic ice cream parlor drinks, perfect for milkshakes, malts, smoothies, and juices.
Powerful 100 watt motor with two speeds lets you easily adjust thickness for smooth or rich milkshakes.
Durable 16 ounce stainless steel mixing cup and rod with weighted base ensure stable, reliable mixing.
Tilt back head and detachable spindle provide easy access and quick cleaning after every use.
Versatile mixer also prepares pancake batter, waffle mixes, and beaten eggs for everyday kitchen tasks.
DiFora Stand Drink Mixer delivers 100W power with two speeds for fast frothing drinks.
Metal double disk stainless steel whisk creates cappuccinos frappes and matcha lattes quietly.
Large 17oz 500ml stainless steel cup is easy to clean by spinning water.
Versatile mixer handles protein shakes Nescafe frappes baby food and omelets in minutes.
Countertop ready design runs quietly uses 120V US plug and does not crush ice.
What We Looked for in Our Testing
Our evaluation process was thorough and methodical. Each milkshake maker went through the same battery of tests to ensure fair comparison.
First, we tested basic vanilla milkshakes using a standard recipe of vanilla ice cream and whole milk. This baseline test revealed how well each machine handled the fundamental task without complications from add-ins or unusual ingredients. We measured consistency, incorporation of ingredients, and blending time.
Next came the stress tests. We made thick peanut butter shakes, cookie-laden creations with whole Oreos, and fruit smoothies with frozen strawberries. These challenges exposed weaknesses in motor power and blade design. Some machines that performed adequately with simple shakes completely bogged down when faced with chunky additions.
We also evaluated practical considerations that matter in daily use. How loud is the motor? Can you hear the television while making an evening shake? How easy is it to clean spindles and cups? Will parts need hand washing, or can everything go in the dishwasher? Does the machine feel sturdy enough to last years of regular use, or does it seem destined for the donation pile after a few months?
Temperature retention proved surprisingly important. The best machines work quickly enough that your shake stays cold and thick throughout the blending process. Slower, less powerful models gave the ice cream time to melt, resulting in a thinner consistency, no matter how carefully you followed the recipe.
Finally, we assessed value. A milkshake maker doesn’t need to cost hundreds of dollars to perform well, but the cheapest options often cut corners in ways that affect performance and longevity. We looked for machines that deliver solid results at a fair price point.
Top Milkshake Maker Our Picks
Walking into our test kitchen on the first day of evaluation, I honestly didn’t expect the Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster to become our team’s go-to machine. It looks unassuming, almost retro, with its simple design. But after our first test run, everything changed.
This classic spindle mixer delivered the kind of performance that reminded us why diners and ice cream shops have used this basic design for generations. The motor runs at two speeds, and while that might sound limited compared to machines with multiple settings, we discovered that two speeds are actually all you need. The lower speed gently incorporates ingredients without splashing, while the higher speed whips everything into that perfect thick consistency that makes you reach for a spoon instead of a straw.
What really won us over was how the DrinkMaster handled our most challenging test: the thick peanut butter shake. We scooped hard ice cream straight from the freezer, added a generous dollop of natural peanut butter, and expected the machine to struggle. Instead, it powered through effortlessly, creating a shake so thick and creamy that it actually stood up in peaks when we pulled the spindle out. The mixing cup barely got warm to the touch, indicating the motor wasn’t straining at all.
The stainless steel mixing cup became our favorite feature during daily use. Unlike plastic cups that retain odors and stain over time, this cup stayed pristine test after test. It’s also the perfect size for two generous servings or one absolutely massive shake, and the handle stays cool even during extended mixing sessions.
Cleanup proved faster than any other machine we tested. The spindle rinses clean in seconds under running water, and the cup goes straight into the dishwasher. There are no hidden crevices where ingredients can hide, no rubber gaskets to remove and replace, no complicated assemblies to figure out. After making an elaborate cookies and cream shake for our afternoon testing, we had everything cleaned and back on the counter in under a minute.
This machine suits anyone who appreciates simplicity and reliability. If you grew up visiting old-fashioned ice cream parlors and want to recreate that experience at home, the DrinkMaster delivers authentic results. It’s also perfect for families because the generous cup size means you can make enough for everyone in one batch. We found ourselves using it almost daily because there’s no friction in the process. You don’t need to plan or commit significant time. Scoop, pour, mix, enjoy.
The DrinkMaster particularly excels if you like thick shakes. Some people prefer a thinner, more drinkable consistency, and this machine can certainly do that. But if you’re someone who believes a proper milkshake should require a spoon, this is your machine. The commercial-grade motor and traditional spindle design create that perfect diner-quality texture that modern blenders struggle to match.
The moment we unboxed the Nostalgia maker, someone on our team said it looked like it belonged in a 1950s soda fountain. They meant it as an observation, but it turned out to be the machine’s greatest strength.
This retro-styled beauty isn’t just about looks, though the chrome finish and vintage aesthetic definitely earn it a permanent spot on the counter instead of hidden in a cabinet. What surprised us during testing was how Nostalgia managed to package serious performance in such a charming design.
The two-speed functionality mirrors the Hamilton Beach approach, but Nostalgia implements it with a slightly different philosophy. The lower speed here is gentler, making it ideal for incorporating delicate ingredients like fresh fruit or cookie pieces without pulverizing them. During our strawberry shake tests, we loved how the berries got chopped and distributed throughout the shake rather than completely liquified. You still get chunks of real strawberry in every sip, creating a more interesting texture experience.
The higher speed proved powerful enough for even the most stubborn frozen ingredients. We tested it with ice cream that had been in the freezer for weeks, rock-hard and barely scoopable. The Nostalgia cut through it without hesitation, and the motor never sounded strained or overworked. This tells us the machine will hold up to regular use without burning out, which is a concern with some cheaper models we tested.
One feature that won over parents on our team was how this machine encourages participation. The simple controls and safe design meant kids as young as eight could operate it with supervision. We watched as testers’ children got excited about making their own custom creations, experimenting with different flavor combinations and add-ins. The Nostalgia turned milkshake making into a fun activity rather than just another kitchen chore.
The included mixing cup is generous without being unwieldy, perfect for one hearty shake or two moderate servings. The chrome finish isn’t just decorative; it’s actually easier to keep clean than we expected. Unlike painted or powder-coated surfaces that can chip and wear, the chrome simply wipes clean and maintains its shine.
During our extended use period, we noticed how the Nostalgia became the machine people reached for when they wanted to enjoy the process as much as the result. There’s something satisfying about the tactile feedback of lowering the spindle into the cup, hearing the motor spin up, and watching the ingredients transform. It engages you in a way that pushing a button on an automatic machine doesn’t.
This maker suits households that value both function and form. If your kitchen aesthetic leans vintage or retro, the Nostalgia looks right at home next to other period-appropriate appliances. But it’s equally appropriate for anyone who wants reliable performance with a touch of personality. The machine practically invites you to use it, and we found ourselves making more milkshakes than planned simply because the experience was enjoyable.
Families with children will particularly appreciate how the Nostalgia turns milkshake making into a shared activity. The straightforward operation builds confidence in young users while still delivering professional-quality results. We also noticed that guests invariably commented on the machine when they saw it, often sharing memories of old ice cream shops or soda fountains from their childhood. It’s a conversation starter that also happens to make excellent milkshakes.
When we first considered including a milk frother in our milkshake maker roundup, there was skepticism on the team. Frothers are designed for lattes and cappuccinos, not thick frozen treats. But the Difora changed our minds completely.
This versatile machine proved that the line between milk frothing and milkshake making is more blurred than we realized. The stand design immediately sets it apart from handheld frothers. You’re not standing there holding it and hoping for the best. You set everything up, press a button, and the Difora does its thing while you prep toppings or clean up from earlier kitchen activities.
Our testing revealed that the Difora excels at a specific type of milkshake that other machines struggle with: the lighter, more drinkable style. If you prefer shakes that pour easily and sip through a straw rather than eat with a spoon, this is your ideal tool. The frothing action incorporates tremendous amounts of air, creating a fluffy, mousse-like texture that’s distinctly different from traditional thick shakes but absolutely delicious in its own right.
We made incredible malt shakes with the Difora, the kind where the malted milk powder gets perfectly distributed throughout, and you end up with that airy consistency that’s become popular at modern milkshake bars. It also proved perfect for protein shakes and healthier alternatives. Adding frozen bananas, protein powder, and almond milk produced a thick, frothy result that felt indulgent despite being relatively nutritious.
The automatic operation became a huge advantage in our morning routine tests. We simulated a busy household where someone wants a quick breakfast shake before heading out. With the Difora, you literally dump ingredients in, press one button, and you’re free to finish getting ready while it blends. The machine stops automatically when finished, so there’s no risk of over-mixing or forgetting about it.
Cleanup proved even easier than the spindle-style mixers. The frothing whisk pops out in seconds and rinses completely clean under the tap. The stainless steel container resists staining and odor retention, staying pristine even after countless chocolate and coffee shakes. Everything is dishwasher safe, but we rarely bothered because hand washing took less than thirty seconds.
The compact footprint surprised us. Despite being a stand mixer, the Difora occupies less counter space than several handheld blenders we tested. The modern, minimalist design looks appropriate in contemporary kitchens, and the brushed stainless finish coordinates with most appliance collections.
During extended testing, we discovered that Difora fills a unique niche. It’s perfect for individuals or couples who want milkshakes regularly but don’t need huge portions. The single-serving capacity might seem limiting, but it actually encourages better portion control and reduces waste. We made exactly the amount we wanted to consume rather than feeling obligated to finish a large batch.
This machine particularly suits health-conscious users. The lighter texture it produces feels less heavy than traditional thick shakes, making it easier to enjoy as a regular treat rather than an occasional indulgence. We created numerous combinations using Greek yogurt, frozen fruit, and natural sweeteners that felt virtuous while still satisfying sweet cravings.
Coffee lovers on our team became obsessed with using the Difora for frozen coffee drinks. Adding cold brew concentrate, a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and a splash of milk produced frothy iced coffee drinks that rivaled expensive coffee shop offerings. The machine paid for itself in saved coffee shop trips within the first month for our most devoted tester.
The Difora also won points for versatility beyond milkshakes. We used it for hot chocolate with perfectly frothed milk, matcha lattes, chai drinks, and even whisked eggs for fluffy omelets. This multi-functionality justifies the counter space even if you only make milkshakes occasionally.
Different Types of Milkshake Makers
The milkshake maker market offers several distinct approaches to blending frozen treats, and understanding these differences helps you choose the right tool for your needs.
Classic spindle-style mixers represent the traditional diner approach. These machines use a rotating spindle that you lower into a metal mixing cup filled with ingredients. The spindle spins at high speed, whipping air into the mixture while blending everything. This is the same technology that’s been used in ice cream shops for decades, and it produces authentic results. The learning curve is minimal since you control the mixing process directly, and you can achieve different textures by varying how long you blend. However, these machines require more active participation than automatic models.
Automatic blender-style makers look more like compact blenders but are optimized for thick, frozen ingredients. You add everything to a pitcher or cup, press a button, and the machine does the work. These tend to be the most convenient option for families, especially when making multiple servings. The trade-off is less control over texture, and some models struggle with very thick mixtures that spindle-style mixers handle easily.
Personal-size makers have gained popularity recently, offering single-serving convenience in compact designs. These are perfect for individuals or couples who want occasional shakes without committing to a larger appliance. Power is usually more limited, so they work best with slightly softer ice cream and thinner recipes.
Professional-grade machines bring commercial capabilities to home kitchens. These powerful units can handle back-to-back servings without overheating, making them ideal if you entertain frequently or have a large family. The investment is substantial, but the performance and durability justify the cost for serious milkshake enthusiasts.
During our testing, we found that spindle-style mixers consistently produced the best texture when properly used. The traditional approach of mixing in a stainless steel cup proved superior for achieving that perfect balance of thickness and creaminess. However, automatic models won points for convenience, especially when making shakes for multiple people.
Essential Tips for Perfect Milkshakes Every Time
Throughout our testing process, we learned numerous tricks and techniques that dramatically improved results regardless of which machine you use.
Start with the right ice cream temperature. This might seem obvious, but it matters more than you’d think. Ice cream straight from the freezer is too hard for most machines to blend efficiently, while ice cream that’s too soft produces thin, runny shakes. We found the sweet spot is letting your ice cream sit at room temperature for three to five minutes before scooping. It should still be quite firm, but your scoop should cut through without bending.
Use the minimum liquid necessary. Beginning milkshake makers almost always add too much milk, resulting in a thin consistency. Start with just two to three tablespoons of liquid per cup of ice cream. You can always add more if needed, but you can’t remove excess liquid once it’s in there. The best milkshakes often use surprisingly little added liquid because quality ice cream already contains plenty of moisture.
Add mix-ins strategically. Cookies, candy pieces, and fruit should be added near the end of mixing, not at the beginning. This prevents over-pulverizing and maintains an interesting texture. We loved having small chunks of Oreo or brownie throughout our shakes rather than having everything completely homogenized.
Chill your mixing cup. This simple step makes a noticeable difference, especially in warm kitchens. Pop your mixing cup in the freezer for fifteen minutes before making your shake. The cold surface prevents premature melting, giving you more time to achieve the perfect consistency.
Don’t over-mix. This was one of our most important discoveries. More mixing time doesn’t equal better results. Once ingredients are fully incorporated and the texture looks right, stop immediately. Continued mixing melts the ice cream, incorporates heat from the motor, and produces a thinner consistency. For most shakes, twenty to thirty seconds of mixing is sufficient.
Choosing the Right Machine for Your Needs
The best milkshake maker for you depends entirely on your specific situation and preferences. Let me walk you through the decision-making process based on what we learned during testing.
If you’re all about authentic diner-style shakes and plan to make them regularly for your family, the Hamilton Beach DrinkMaster represents the best combination of performance, durability, and value. The classic spindle design produces superior texture, and the commercial-grade motor will outlast cheaper alternatives for years. You’ll appreciate the generous cup size when making multiple servings, and the minimal cleanup means you won’t avoid using it because it’s too much hassle.
Families with children or anyone who values aesthetic appeal alongside functionality should seriously consider the Nostalgia Two-Speed maker. The retro design adds personality to your kitchen while delivering performance that matches or exceeds more utilitarian options. The straightforward operation makes it accessible for younger users, and the build quality suggests it will become a long-lasting fixture in your home. This is the machine you’ll still be using and enjoying ten years from now.
The Difora Stand Milk Frother suits individuals and couples who want convenient, single-serving options with maximum versatility. If you’re health-conscious and want to make protein shakes alongside occasional indulgent treats, the Difora handles both beautifully. The automatic operation and lightning-fast cleanup make it perfect for busy lifestyles where convenience matters as much as results. Coffee enthusiasts will particularly appreciate the expanded functionality beyond just milkshakes.
Budget considerations also play a role. All three of our recommended machines offer excellent value at their respective price points, but they represent different investment levels. Consider how frequently you’ll realistically use the machine. Occasional users might prioritize lower upfront cost, while daily users should focus on durability and features that reduce friction in regular use.
Counter space is another practical consideration. The spindle-style mixers require dedicated space because you can’t easily tuck them into a cabinet between uses. The Difora’s compact footprint makes it easier to accommodate in smaller kitchens. Think about your available space and storage options when making your choice.
Maintenance and Longevity
Taking proper care of your milkshake maker ensures years of reliable performance. Our testing included evaluation of long-term durability and maintenance requirements.
Clean immediately after each use. This simple habit prevents the hardest cleanup challenges. Ice cream and milk residue become exponentially harder to remove once they dry. Rinse components under warm water right away, and you’ll never face the frustration of scrubbing crusted-on ingredients.
For spindle-style mixers, pay special attention to the spindle shaft where it enters the motor housing. Wipe this area after each use to prevent buildup that can eventually affect motor performance. We found that a damp cloth takes two seconds to wipe this area clean, preventing problems down the road.
Store machines in dry locations. Moisture is the enemy of electric motors. Make sure all components are completely dry before storage, and avoid keeping machines near sinks where they might get splashed regularly.
According to our research, properly maintained small kitchen appliances typically last five to ten years with regular use. The machines we recommend are all built to meet or exceed this expectation, but your maintenance habits significantly impact actual longevity.
Periodically check for worn parts. Spindles can eventually wear down from regular use, and rubber gaskets may need replacement on automatic models. Catching these issues early prevents larger problems and extends overall machine life.
